Blog Layout

Why in the world would I need to develop a budget?

Greg Squires • Jan 02, 2013

Remember … the first step in fixing any problem is to first identify what is broken – do you know what is broken in your business?

I have been a proponent of annual budgeting for quite some time. When my clients first hear me advocating the development of annual budgets they usually have one of the following reactions:


1) Look at me as though I have snakes slithering out of my eyes while screaming that there is no way they could possibly benefit from trying to forecast the upcoming year’s expenses nor would they stand for any process that would constrain their on-the-fly expenditures


2)  Readily adopt the process and feed off of the resulting management information 


If I started this conversation with you, in which camp would you fall?


Annual budgeting is a process that is much more involved and beneficial than simply applying next year’s projected milk price onto this year’s milk production, adding 2% to this year’s expenses and calling the resulting product “next year’s budget.” Let me describe the process from my experience.


Begin with a planning discussion

Starting the budgeting process with a planning discussion involving all department managers. Recap this year’s accomplishments and challenges. Review recently-implemented management practices and determine those which have yielded positive results and those which have been reconsidered (or should be reconsidered). What profitability gaps do we want to tackle next year? Discuss new procedures and protocols that might be targeted for the coming year and their implications for operating expenses and or incomes. Are there capital investments that should be considered which would improve long-term efficiency and profitability? Is our labor and management pool properly configured? How will our incomes and expenses differ next year vs. the current year?


This conversation and the resulting answers to sometimes tough questions have several side benefits including the involvement of the entire management team in proactive strategic planning. (I encourage farms of all sizes to embrace the term “management team” because regardless of whether you have 50 cows or 50,000, there is likely more than one person involved in the overall decision-making process at your dairy.) Having the entire management team involved also improves the likelihood that everyone will take greater ownership of their area(s) of responsibility and more proactively manage with greater empowerment.


Development a monthly cash flow

The next step of the process is to lay out projected monthly incomes and expenditures for the upcoming fiscal year. Incomes should be adjusted to reflect the ebb and flow of fresh cows and heifers throughout the year. Feed expenses should be likewise adjusted for the number of animals at various stages of their production cycles as well as projected feed inventories throughout the growing season. It is important to include projected interest expenses and principal payments in your projected cash budget.


After all incomes and expenses have been projected, make estimates of projected capital expenditures for targeted capital improvements and purchases. Next account for any expected structured loan proceeds in conjunction with your capital projects. After all sources and uses of cash have been considered, calculate monthly net cash flow.


Compare budget to actual results

The final step of the process is its ultimate purpose and most important benefit. Develop a report which shows both the current month’s budget as well as your actual results. In other columns, compare year-to-date budgeted numbers with actual results. See the partial example demonstrated in Figure 1.  Wherever possible the reader’s eye should be drawn toward the most important points in the report – which income or expense categories were on target (green) and which ones were on or off target by more than 10-15% (red). If possible, also point out the big-ticket items (milk income and feed, labor and replacement expenses for example). Ideally the report will paint a picture that can be quickly interpreted and used to direct management’s attention.


It is also beneficial to index revenues and expenses on a per-unit basis ($/cow/year and $/cwt.). This monthly comparison will provide owners and managers with an invaluable opportunity to greatly improve their familiarity with the business’ finances and underlying trends which will help focus management’s attention to areas most needing attention. Many dairy producers would benefit from a greater understanding of how and where cash is gained and lost in their businesses.


So the next time you hear the phrase “annual budgeting” what will your reaction be? Will you adopt the practice and learn something about your business or will you see slithering snakes? Remember … the first step in fixing any problem is to first identify what is broken – do you know what is broken in your business?

Download PDF Version
By Greg Squires 25 Aug, 2021
The managerial succession planning process can clearly benefit from a proactive process of optimally aligning skills, talents and passions with roles for both non-owner employees as well as owners.
By Greg Squires 01 Jul, 2021
Vital to the success of any farm business is that all of the tasks categorized as important to the farm but perceived as something a farmer doesn't do well eventually become part of a farmer's "Do Well" list.
By Greg Squires 07 Nov, 2017
“Success breeds complacency. Complacency breeds failure. Only the paranoid survive.” How paranoid are you willing to become?
By Greg Squires 21 Mar, 2013
Any progress that has ever been realized throughout history is the direct result of change. While this is an indisputable fact, many people say they just don’t like change. Here is how psychologist Dr. Heidi Grant Halvorson explains... 
By Greg Squires 12 Aug, 2012
“It isn't that they can't see the solution. It's that they can't see the problem.”
By Greg Squires 11 Jun, 2012
Several readers of my last article emailed me with a question that I have repeatedly heard from customers and audiences for many years: Are there traits or characteristics which are common to successful dairy farms? If you were to ask 100 different industry professionals and dairy producers, you would undoubtedly see 100 different lists of attributes most closely linked to success. As Dairy Enterprise Services continues its work on dairy operations across the U.S., the following are among the most common characteristics I observe: Intense reproductive management Many successful dairy producers place a high priority on breeding cows to maintain relatively short calving intervals. This focus is not only rationalized by higher milk production but greater internal herd growth. Set expectations Regardless of herd size, every dairy owner relies on other sets of hands to complete the work that is necessary to operate a dairy business. One of the most common disconnects between a manager and subordinate is a basic lack of understanding of what is expected of the job, role, or task. While this trait is clearly not universal among successful farms, many of the best operators have developed a discipline of setting clear and measurable expectations of not only those people who are on their payrolls but their advisors as well. Manage risk This trait may be one of the more arguable points on my list but almost by definition, a successful business must survive any risks that could potentially bring about its collapse. The counterpoint to this observation is that many very successful dairy producers are also among the most significant and calculated risk-takers. Risk comes in many forms including market (milk/feed/land prices), safety (liability), financial (leverage, interest rates), production (milk, disease, reproduction), and counter party (contracts). Mitigation of these risks must constantly be matched against the business’ ability to survive a worst-case scenario in one or more of these areas. While risk management is never perfect and always comes at a price, many good managers are vigilant in looking for cost-effective tools to mitigate sources of risk. Possess an attitude of excellence While this is one of the least quantifiable qualities on my list, it certainly is one of the more pervasive. What I’m describing is a never-ending attitude of doing the right things and doing things right. I once had a customer who, when working through a SWAT analysis replied that one of the strengths of their business was “we sweat excellence.” He offered the comment not as a boast or an arrogant jibe but was simply trying to state that they treated all of their selected processes as being important. If something was important to them, they strived to do it right every time, all the time. Take care of people Successful dairy operations are in a position of success largely because they have surrounded themselves with good people, and people who they want to retain. They are also surrounded by good neighbors to whom they in turn want to be good neighbors. Therefore, many successful dairy owners and managers are careful to be considerate and respectful of members of their staff, their communities and their industry. Focus on milk quality and udder health This is probably one of the more universal traits found in successful operations. Managing for improved SCC and udder health is an obvious economic driver considering their combined impact on milk production, milk premiums, and operating costs. Many of these excellent operators have instilled the notion among their staffs that they are in the business of producing food for people and it is sometimes amazing how impactful this concept can be, particularly with milking crews. Passionate about information As an industry, we still do a pretty poor job of utilizing information (financial reports, production summaries, scorecards, etc.) to make informed management decisions. However I am confident that I commonly see these tools being utilized in well managed businesses. An old saying goes something like: “You can’t manage what you don’t measure.” Actually it was Peter Drucker who said “If you can't measure it, you can't manage it.” Our missed opportunity more often isn’t that we can’t measure it…more commonly we simply don’t measure it. Aggressively manage costs When compared to its ability to determine milk price, a dairy operation has much greater influence on its costs of production; many successful dairy operators manage costs very closely. There are two common standards of measuring costs in a dairy operation: cost per hundredweight of milk produced and cost per cow, per year. Obviously cost per hundredweight can be influenced by both raw costs as well as the volume of milk produced and I am referring to the management of raw costs. Many of these operators could be described as “tight with a buck.” Understand the importance of growth There are two reasons why I believe this is a common factor in successful operations. First, our industry has been consolidating for decades. With consolidation, efficiency targets evolve and scale becomes an increasingly significant dynamic (not a sole determiner of success, just one factor). Second and more importantly, growth can become an important factor in a business’ ability to sustain its mission of providing a desired standard of living for its owners. As succeeding generations come into the business, there will be “more mouths to feed,” so to speak. Also, time and inflation have a way of eroding the ability of each cow to generate sufficient net income to meet its owner’s standard of living. I certainly don’t intend this list to be either inclusive or exclusive. I realize there are additional attributes which may be associated with successful operations and I believe that a dairy that may not possess one or more of these characteristics can still be successful. I do however associate each of these skills and priorities of management with many successful dairy operations. Of course we all must be mindful of our own unique idea of what defines a “successful” dairy operation. As a business owner, it is your right and prerogative (if not obligation) to determine what success means to you and your fellow owners. Of one thing I am certain: it is of the rarest of circumstances that success is realized purely by accident. As Confucius once said, “Success depends upon previous preparation, and without such preparation there is sure to be failure.”
By Greg Squires 11 Apr, 2012
"Management is efficiency in climbing the ladder of success; leadership determines whether the ladder is leaning against the right wall."
By Greg Squires 24 Feb, 2012
If I am charged with the expectation of helping someone develop a road map for their business, it’s a given that I must have a comprehensive understanding of where they’ve been, where they are now and where they want to go.
By Greg Squires 01 Nov, 2011
"Realize that the greatest personal satisfaction you will experience as CEO of your family business will come from the legacy of its continued, multigenerational success."
By Greg Squires 22 Sep, 2011
How many multi-generational farms can you think of where Mom and Dad are in their 60s or 70s and still control the checkbook and general ledger?
More Posts
Share by: